| 1 |  Ollie PearcePenalty goals: 6 |  York City | 34 |
| 2 |  Matt RushPenalty goals: 0 |  Boreham Wood | 27 |
| 3 |  Emmanuel DieseruvwePenalty goals: 2 |  Rochdale | 27 |
| 4 |  Will HarrisPenalty goals: 1 |  FC Halifax Town | 22 |
| 5 |  Jack NolanPenalty goals: 2 |  Morecambe | 19 |
| 6 |  Regan LinneyPenalty goals: 3 |  Carlisle United | 19 |
| 7 |  Callum RobertsPenalty goals: 5 |  Scunthorpe United | 19 |
| 8 |  Danny WhitehallPenalty goals: 5 | Scunthorpe United | 18 |
| 9 |  Josh StonesPenalty goals: 1 | York City | 17 |
| 10 |  Aaron BlairPenalty goals: 2 |  Eastleigh | 17 |
| 10 |  Andrew DallasPenalty goals: 2 |  Southend United | 17 |
| 12 |  Zak BruntPenalty goals: 5 | Boreham Wood | 17 |
| 13 |  Oliver SandersonPenalty goals: 0 |  Woking | 16 |
| 14 |  Kyle McAllisterPenalty goals: 6 |  Forest Green Rovers | 16 |
| 15 |  Abdul AbdulmalikPenalty goals: 0 | Boreham Wood | 15 |
| 15 |  Gus Scott-MorrissPenalty goals: 0 | Southend United | 15 |
| 17 |  Declan HowePenalty goals: 0 | Scunthorpe United | 14 |
| 17 |  Micah ObieroPenalty goals: 0 |  Wealdstone | 14 |
| 19 |  Georgie KellyPenalty goals: 1 | Carlisle United | 13 |
| 20 |  Alex NewbyPenalty goals: 0 | York City | 12 |
| 20 |  Oliver LynchPenalty goals: 0 |  Tamworth | 12 |
| 22 |  Alex ReidPenalty goals: 2 |  Hartlepool United | 12 |
| 22 |  Lewis SimperPenalty goals: 2 |  Sutton United | 12 |
| 24 |  Josh HmamiPenalty goals: 3 | FC Halifax Town | 12 |
| 25 |  Lewis RichardsonPenalty goals: 0 | Boreham Wood | 11 |
| 26 |  Jimmy KnowlesPenalty goals: 1 |  Altrincham | 11 |
| 26 |  Luke ArmstrongPenalty goals: 1 | Carlisle United | 11 |
| 28 |  Lenell John-LewisPenalty goals: 2 |  Boston United | 11 |
| 29 |  Harry BeautymanPenalty goals: 3 | Woking | 11 |
| 30 |  Harvey SaundersPenalty goals: 0 | Eastleigh | 10 |
| 30 |  Joe SbarraPenalty goals: 0 |  Solihull Moors | 10 |
| 30 |  Lewis WalkerPenalty goals: 0 |  Braintree Town | 10 |
| 30 |  Tom KnowlesPenalty goals: 0 | Forest Green Rovers | 10 |
| 34 |  Kain AdomPenalty goals: 1 |  Gateshead FC | 10 |
| 34 |  Stefan MolsPenalty goals: 1 | Tamworth | 10 |
| 36 |  Alfie BeestinPenalty goals: 0 | Scunthorpe United | 9 |
| 36 |  Brandon NjokuPenalty goals: 0 | Sutton United | 9 |
| 36 |  Dan CreaneyPenalty goals: 0 | Tamworth | 9 |
| 36 |  Devante RodneyPenalty goals: 0 | Rochdale | 9 |
| 36 |  Harry ChapmanPenalty goals: 0 | Gateshead FC | 9 |
| 36 |  Jacob WakelingPenalty goals: 0 | Solihull Moors | 9 |
| 36 |  Oliver CrankshawPenalty goals: 0 | Altrincham | 9 |
| 36 |  Tom CursonsPenalty goals: 0 | Boston United | 9 |
| 44 |  Conor WilkinsonPenalty goals: 1 | Solihull Moors | 9 |
| 45 |  Alex HuntPenalty goals: 3 | York City | 9 |
| 46 |  Ryan HillPenalty goals: 6 |  Aldershot Town | 9 |
| 47 |  Charley KendallPenalty goals: 0 | Southend United | 8 |
| 47 |  Darius LipsiucPenalty goals: 0 | Solihull Moors | 8 |
| 47 |  Ian HendersonPenalty goals: 0 | Rochdale | 8 |
| 47 |  Kai JenningsPenalty goals: 0 | Sutton United | 8 |
