| 1 | Shaq GwengwePenalty goals: 9 |  Poole Town FC | 43 |
| 2 |  Ryan SeagerPenalty goals: 4 |  Havant and Waterlooville | 37 |
| 3 |  Jason CowleyPenalty goals: 2 |  Halesowen Town FC | 30 |
| 4 | Josh AllenPenalty goals: 1 |  Real Bedford | 28 |
| 5 | Kane SimpsonPenalty goals: 1 |  Gloucester City | 27 |
| 6 | Jack RobertsPenalty goals: 2 |  Spalding United | 27 |
| 7 |  Dawid RogalskiPenalty goals: 3 |  Walton and Hersham | 27 |
| 7 |  Olly MartinPenalty goals: 3 |  Hebburn Town | 27 |
| 9 |  Jake HutchinsonPenalty goals: 1 |  Folkestone Invicta | 25 |
| 10 |  Johl PowellPenalty goals: 0 | Walton and Hersham | 22 |
| 11 |  Bartosz CybulskiPenalty goals: 0 | Spalding United | 21 |
| 12 |  Daniel OgunleyePenalty goals: 1 |  Brentwood Town | 21 |
| 13 |  Nicky WalkerPenalty goals: 0 |  Cleethorpes Town | 20 |
| 14 | Jonathan LaceyPenalty goals: 1 |  Berkhamsted | 20 |
| 15 | Bradley WilsonPenalty goals: 2 |  Chertsey Town | 20 |
| 16 | Alex HernandezPenalty goals: 4 |  Cray Wanderers | 20 |
| 17 | Edward PanterPenalty goals: 3 |  Kettering Town FC | 19 |
| 17 |  Zak GoodsonPenalty goals: 3 |  Quorn | 19 |
| 19 |  George MoorePenalty goals: 1 |  Uxbridge | 18 |
| 20 | Leo SeryPenalty goals: 0 |  St Albans | 17 |
| 21 |  Jake McCarthyPenalty goals: 2 |  Sholing | 17 |
| 21 | Ollie BoxPenalty goals: 2 |  Dartford | 17 |
| 23 |  Michael FoliviPenalty goals: 5 | Sholing | 17 |
| 24 |  Michael RichensPenalty goals: 6 |  St. Ives Town FC | 17 |
| 25 | Ben StevensPenalty goals: 0 | Real Bedford | 16 |
| 25 |  Jack WoodPenalty goals: 0 | Walton and Hersham | 16 |
| 25 | Max FiddesPenalty goals: 0 | Cray Wanderers | 16 |
| 25 |  Yusifu CeesayPenalty goals: 0 | Spalding United | 16 |
| 29 |  Joe HanksPenalty goals: 3 | Gloucester City | 16 |
| 30 |  Anthony DwyerPenalty goals: 0 |  Rushall Olympic | 15 |
| 30 |  Brandon GoodshipPenalty goals: 0 |  Weymouth | 15 |
| 32 |  Jay FitzmartinPenalty goals: 1 |  FC United of Manchester | 15 |
| 33 |  Adam Le FondrePenalty goals: 2 | FC United of Manchester | 15 |
| 33 |  Ben HardcastlePenalty goals: 2 |  Warrington Rylands | 15 |
| 33 |  George VorsterPenalty goals: 2 |  Burgess Hill Town | 15 |
| 36 |  Jordan ThewlisPenalty goals: 3 |  Guiseley | 15 |
| 37 |  Ewan BangePenalty goals: 4 |  Bamber Bridge | 15 |
| 37 | Kevin HayesPenalty goals: 4 |  Stockton Town | 15 |
| 39 | Elliot LongPenalty goals: 0 |  Billericay | 14 |
| 39 | Jack DeanPenalty goals: 0 |  Farnham Town | 14 |
| 39 |  Jack MazzonePenalty goals: 0 |  Bracknell Town | 14 |
| 39 |  Joe PigottPenalty goals: 0 | Folkestone Invicta | 14 |
| 43 |  Chris WhelpdalePenalty goals: 1 | Burgess Hill Town | 14 |
| 43 |  Eddie DsanePenalty goals: 1 | Dartford | 14 |
| 43 | Finley HolmesPenalty goals: 1 | Halesowen Town FC | 14 |
| 46 |  Leon LobjoitPenalty goals: 2 |  Potters Bar Town | 14 |
| 46 | Will FletcherPenalty goals: 2 |  Wimborne Town | 14 |
| 48 |  Charlie LambertPenalty goals: 3 |  Whitehawk | 14 |
| 49 | Alfie CerulliPenalty goals: 4 | Billericay | 14 |
| 50 | Oliver PetersPenalty goals: 7 |  Aveley | 14 |
