| 1 |  Darren SmithPenalty goals: 0 |  Detroit City | 11 |
| 2 |  Peter WilsonPenalty goals: 3 |  Oakland Roots | 10 |
| 3 |  Johnny RodriguezPenalty goals: 1 |  Las Vegas Lights FC | 9 |
| 4 |  Ihsan SackoPenalty goals: 5 |  Phoenix Rising | 9 |
| 4 |  Khori BennettPenalty goals: 5 |  Colorado Springs Switchbacks | 9 |
| 6 |  Rubio RubínPenalty goals: 1 |  El Paso Locomotive | 8 |
| 7 |  Bruno RendónPenalty goals: 0 |  Indy Eleven | 7 |
| 7 |  Colton SwanPenalty goals: 0 |  Charleston Battery | 7 |
| 9 |  Kieran SadlierPenalty goals: 3 |  Sporting JAX | 7 |
| 10 |  JJ WilliamsPenalty goals: 0 |  Rhode Island | 6 |
| 10 |  Thorleifur ÚlfarssonPenalty goals: 0 |  Loudoun United | 6 |
| 12 |  Albert DikwaPenalty goals: 2 |  Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC | 6 |
| 13 |  Amando MorenoPenalty goals: 0 | El Paso Locomotive | 5 |
| 13 |  Dmitriy ErofeevPenalty goals: 0 |  San Antonio | 5 |
| 13 |  Jansen WilsonPenalty goals: 0 |  Louisville City | 5 |
| 13 |  Jojea KwizeraPenalty goals: 0 | Rhode Island | 5 |
| 13 |  Jorge HernándezPenalty goals: 0 | San Antonio | 5 |
| 13 |  Maalique FosterPenalty goals: 0 | Charleston Battery | 5 |
| 13 |  Markus AndersonPenalty goals: 0 |  Brooklyn | 5 |
| 13 |  Rémi CabralPenalty goals: 0 |  FC Tulsa | 5 |
| 13 |  Wolfgang PrenticePenalty goals: 0 | Oakland Roots | 5 |
| 13 |  Yaniv BaziniPenalty goals: 0 |  Orange County SC | 5 |
| 23 |  MD MyersPenalty goals: 1 |  Tampa Bay Rowdies | 5 |
| 24 |  Alex MéndezPenalty goals: 2 | El Paso Locomotive | 5 |
| 25 |  Aaron MolloyPenalty goals: 0 |  Lexington | 4 |
| 25 |  Alex CrognalePenalty goals: 0 | San Antonio | 4 |
| 25 |  Chris DonovanPenalty goals: 0 | Louisville City | 4 |
| 25 |  Emil JääskeläinenPenalty goals: 0 | Sporting JAX | 4 |
| 25 |  Jürgen LocadiaPenalty goals: 0 |  Miami FC 2 | 4 |
| 25 |  Lyam MacKinnonPenalty goals: 0 | Orange County SC | 4 |
| 25 |  Oalex AndersonPenalty goals: 0 | Las Vegas Lights FC | 4 |
| 25 |  Ousmane SyllaPenalty goals: 0 | Orange County SC | 4 |
| 25 |  Stefan StojanovicPenalty goals: 0 | Brooklyn | 4 |
| 34 |  Riley BidoisPenalty goals: 1 |  Monterey Bay | 4 |
| 35 |  Emilio YcazaPenalty goals: 2 | Charleston Battery | 4 |
| 35 |  Tyler PasherPenalty goals: 2 |  Birmingham Legion | 4 |
| 37 |  Abraham OkyerePenalty goals: 0 | Las Vegas Lights FC | 3 |
| 37 |  Adrien PérezPenalty goals: 0 | Colorado Springs Switchbacks | 3 |
| 37 |  Alessandro MilesiPenalty goals: 0 | Miami FC 2 | 3 |
| 37 |  Barry CoffeyPenalty goals: 0 |  Hartford Athletic | 3 |
| 37 |  Christian SortoPenalty goals: 0 | San Antonio | 3 |
| 37 |  Ilijah PaulPenalty goals: 0 | Monterey Bay | 3 |
| 37 |  Josh O'BrienPenalty goals: 0 | Indy Eleven | 3 |
| 37 |  Kyle EdwardsPenalty goals: 0 |  Sacramento Republic | 3 |
| 37 |  Leo AfonsoPenalty goals: 0 | Rhode Island | 3 |
| 37 |  Louis PerezPenalty goals: 0 | Tampa Bay Rowdies | 3 |
| 37 |  Mathieu NdongoPenalty goals: 0 | Miami FC 2 | 3 |
| 37 |  Nico BenalcázarPenalty goals: 0 | Orange County SC | 3 |
| 37 |  Nicolas FirminoPenalty goals: 0 | Lexington | 3 |
| 37 |  Rafferty PedderPenalty goals: 0 | Sporting JAX | 3 |
